By Jameson Mutua
The High Court of Kenya has issued a historic judgment declaring that farmers have the constitutional right to save, share and exchange indigenous seeds. The ruling strikes down punitive provisions of the Seed and Plant Varieties Act, marking a major victory for food sovereignty advocates and setting a global precedent in favour of Farmer-Managed Seed Systems.
The court declared unconstitutional the legal provisions that criminalised the sale or exchange of unregistered seeds and exposed farmers to jail terms of up to two years or fines of up to one million shillings. For years, these restrictions had placed control of the country’s seed systems in the hands of multinational companies. The court’s decision dismantles this dominance and restores farmers’ authority over the seeds they rely on for their livelihoods.
Samuel Wathome, a smallholder farmer and lead petitioner in the case, welcomed the judgment with emotion. He said he had waited many years for this moment and that the ruling restores dignity and freedom to farming communities. “My grandmother saved seeds, and today the court has said I can do the same for my grandchildren without fear of police or prison. Today, the farmer is king again,” he said.
Food sovereignty groups described the ruling as transformative. Greenpeace Africa Food Campaigner Elizabeth Atieno said the decision affirms that farmer seeds are an integral part of Kenya’s heritage. According to her, the court’s affirmation of indigenous seeds represents a significant pushback against corporate control of food systems. “This is not just a legal win. It is a victory for our culture, our resilience and our future,” she said.
Gideon Muya, Programs Officer at the Biodiversity and Biosafety Association of Kenya, said the ruling protects biodiversity and strengthens the country’s ability to withstand climate shocks. He noted that indigenous seeds contain valuable genetic diversity that cannot be replaced by commercial varieties. “The court has recognised that you cannot patent nature’s heritage. We have reclaimed the right to choose what we plant and what we eat,” he said.
Agroecologist Claire Nasike said the judgment should compel policymakers to prioritise the protection of farmers’ seed rights. She described seed as a vital resource that shapes the destiny of future generations. She said it is encouraging that the right to save, share and exchange seeds has been returned to the hands of Kenyan farmers.
In the judgment, Justice Rhoda Rutto found that the contested sections of the Act violated constitutional protections by granting seed inspectors excessive powers, restricting farmers from processing or selling seeds unless registered as seed merchants and giving plant breeders extensive proprietary rights at the expense of farmers. The judge also faulted provisions that criminalised saving or sharing seeds from previous harvests without notifying seed proprietors.
The Law Society of Kenya, which supported the petition, said the court correctly affirmed that farmers’ rights take precedence over restrictive laws influenced by commercial interests. Legal Counsel Wambugu Wanjohi said the ruling sets a strong precedent for Kenya and the African continent, signalling the need for seed laws that respect farmer autonomy.
Greenpeace Africa and partner organisations have urged the Ministry of Agriculture to swiftly update national policies in line with the ruling and formally recognise Farmer-Managed Seed Systems as a cornerstone of Kenya’s food security.
5
t
